Page 1 of 1

Can anyone tell me what this is?

Posted: 01 Apr 2004, 09:34
by Monsoon
I was sold this fish as an algae-eating catfish, I just want to be certain about what it is so that I can provide the right conditions for it.
I have tried ID'ing it from body type to begin with, but I can't find anything that resembles it very well.
If it is of relevance, I bought it in Shanghai, China.
I also have a syn. which I was hoping to get a good id on, but the picture is really bad, I'll try to take some better ones later.

http://homepage.mac.com/delyth/PhotoAlbum1.html

Thanks for any help.

Posted: 01 Apr 2004, 10:18
by hippyguy
I'm afraid your fish isn't actually a catfish but a loach, probably a botia longiventralis. It will grow to about 12cm long and will not eat algae, but may graze through it on plant leaves, looking for scraps of food. Hope this helps :D

Posted: 01 Apr 2004, 11:23
by Monsoon
Thanks for the quick reply!
I had a feeling it might not be. :? It hasn't been doing much grazing! Guess I'd better go find out about those.
I'm sure my syno will cope well though! :)
I just need to get some better pictures of him.

Posted: 01 Apr 2004, 11:57
by CatBrat
Hi,

I had a fish that looked just like your one. It was sold to me as a Twelve Bared Red Lipped Loach. It became a problem in my tank as it started to eat the fins of some of my fish. I eventually put it an outside pond with gold fish (I had no where else to put it), but I did not expect it to survive. I checked it a couple of weeks later and it was doing fine. I then moved it to its own pond as I was worried about the gold fish, but I it some how disappeared.

Cheers, CatBrat

Posted: 01 Apr 2004, 13:56
by Silurus
Your syno is .

Posted: 02 Apr 2004, 05:21
by metallhd
Monsoon - loaches are just excellent for eating snails, that is their 'strength', their algae eating prowess remains, um, undocumented? :roll: The common picks for algae include the so-called algae eaters themselves (ie, Chinese), some of which get big and aggressive, otocinclus, and pl*co's, notably the bristlenose variety. That's a nice looking fish, at any rate. Good luck!

Posted: 02 Apr 2004, 20:44
by sidguppy
check out Leptobotia spp on http://www.loaches.com

your mystery fish is right in there!!
pretty fish btw and a rare find too.
congrats!

Posted: 03 Apr 2004, 04:57
by Monsoon
Wow, it's rare? :shock:
I got two of them for a dollar each! :D He is pretty though, I am quite attached to him.

I had noticed that a couple of baby snails in the tank had gone recently! :) They disappeared pretty quick too, they were on the glass, and then about an hour later they were nowhere to be seen. I think they arrived on some new plants I got, I was starting to worry there might be a problem with them.

Thanks for IDing my catfish too! No wonder I couldn't find him, the juvenile looks quite different.

I have a couple of chinese algae eaters, which are quite small and ok at the minute, but I am actively looking for replacements, as I have seen larger ones in a friends tank and you're right, they are pretty mean. I'm keeping my eyes open for a bristlenose, but have yet to find one. If I do, do you think he would be ok with the other syno?

Monsoon

Posted: 03 Apr 2004, 15:31
by Silurus
Wow, it's rare?
Not where you come from. Leptobotia is probably the most common botiine loach in the Changjiang drainage.