Pseudomystus Siamensis Tankmates?
Posted: 17 Dec 2013, 16:41
EDIT: I no longer need assistance choosing tankmates. My tank has been stocked. See my post below for updates and pictures.
I am looking for some tankmates for my Pseudomystus siamensis. I just got him a nice new 55 gallon long tank that I plan to fully plant. It'll have lots of caves and driftwood for hiding as well. I did a lot of research looking for different fish I could house him with, and also asked on another forum, one for planted tanks, to get opinions on the species I found. That only got me more frustrated and lost on what to house him with, so I figured I'd look to the experts and ask people who've actually kept this fish before.
Based on what I've read on this site and a few others, he can be kept with peaceful american cichlids (which I don't dislike, but have no interest in getting), larger cyprinids, or larger characins. I've also seen places that say tank mates no less than 3" can work.
The fish I was looking at based on this information were Denison Barbs (school of 6) or Tiger Barbs (school of 8 - 12). On the other forum I was told that the Denisons couldn't be housed in a 55 and that Tigers would eventually be eaten. Is that accurate? I know cats tend to have big mouths, but Tiger Barbs are supposed to get up to 3" in length, half the size of a full grown asian bumblebee, and are fairly round in shape. Would my cat eat them, or even go after a school of decent sized fish?
In addition, I have a couple other fish from existing tanks that I'd like to move up to my 55:
- 1 Rosy Red Minnow, that is a full grown 3" fish and very fast - I was also told this fish would get eaten
- 1 Red Tailed Black Shark, currently about 3"
- 2 bristlenose plecos, one albino and one regular, at 1.5" - 2" currently, but growing rapidly
Would I have problems with those fish and my bumblebee cat? The people on the other forum talk like bumblebees are eating machines and will devastate tank populations of anything remotely smaller than them, but here I've seen them referred to as peaceful. Mine is currently kept alone, but if anything seems timid. What are these fish really like?
I'm also open to other suggestions. I'd love to get some other cat species if I've got the space. I'm basing my water parameters around my bumblebee and my plants, so I'm aiming for a water temperature around 76 degrees. My water's pH is naturally a bit high, but the tank will have driftwood and possibly peat that should keep it at a more mid-range level.
Other fish I've considered:
- Swordtails (Hoping he'll be content picking off the fry and leave the adults alone)
- Glass cats (Worried my bumblebee or RTBS would bother them, and that my plant lights would be too bright, though I will be getting some floaters in addition to the cover provided by the rooted plants, caves, and driftwood)
- A similarly sized predatory fish that occupies the mid-upper water levels and is active during the day?
- Another bumblebee (Thought I'd pick up a female and hope that maybe I would stumble across the necessary breeding conditions - I know captive breeding hasn't been documented, but even if they didn't I'd just love to have another one of these awesome cats) [EDIT: Just saw that there has been a successful breeding]
I definitely appreciate any input. This is something I've been struggling with, and I thought I had it figured out, but now based on what I heard from the other forum, my plans are pretty much down the drain.
I am looking for some tankmates for my Pseudomystus siamensis. I just got him a nice new 55 gallon long tank that I plan to fully plant. It'll have lots of caves and driftwood for hiding as well. I did a lot of research looking for different fish I could house him with, and also asked on another forum, one for planted tanks, to get opinions on the species I found. That only got me more frustrated and lost on what to house him with, so I figured I'd look to the experts and ask people who've actually kept this fish before.
Based on what I've read on this site and a few others, he can be kept with peaceful american cichlids (which I don't dislike, but have no interest in getting), larger cyprinids, or larger characins. I've also seen places that say tank mates no less than 3" can work.
The fish I was looking at based on this information were Denison Barbs (school of 6) or Tiger Barbs (school of 8 - 12). On the other forum I was told that the Denisons couldn't be housed in a 55 and that Tigers would eventually be eaten. Is that accurate? I know cats tend to have big mouths, but Tiger Barbs are supposed to get up to 3" in length, half the size of a full grown asian bumblebee, and are fairly round in shape. Would my cat eat them, or even go after a school of decent sized fish?
In addition, I have a couple other fish from existing tanks that I'd like to move up to my 55:
- 1 Rosy Red Minnow, that is a full grown 3" fish and very fast - I was also told this fish would get eaten
- 1 Red Tailed Black Shark, currently about 3"
- 2 bristlenose plecos, one albino and one regular, at 1.5" - 2" currently, but growing rapidly
Would I have problems with those fish and my bumblebee cat? The people on the other forum talk like bumblebees are eating machines and will devastate tank populations of anything remotely smaller than them, but here I've seen them referred to as peaceful. Mine is currently kept alone, but if anything seems timid. What are these fish really like?
I'm also open to other suggestions. I'd love to get some other cat species if I've got the space. I'm basing my water parameters around my bumblebee and my plants, so I'm aiming for a water temperature around 76 degrees. My water's pH is naturally a bit high, but the tank will have driftwood and possibly peat that should keep it at a more mid-range level.
Other fish I've considered:
- Swordtails (Hoping he'll be content picking off the fry and leave the adults alone)
- Glass cats (Worried my bumblebee or RTBS would bother them, and that my plant lights would be too bright, though I will be getting some floaters in addition to the cover provided by the rooted plants, caves, and driftwood)
- A similarly sized predatory fish that occupies the mid-upper water levels and is active during the day?
- Another bumblebee (Thought I'd pick up a female and hope that maybe I would stumble across the necessary breeding conditions - I know captive breeding hasn't been documented, but even if they didn't I'd just love to have another one of these awesome cats) [EDIT: Just saw that there has been a successful breeding]
I definitely appreciate any input. This is something I've been struggling with, and I thought I had it figured out, but now based on what I heard from the other forum, my plans are pretty much down the drain.
I'll definitely check out those species and see what I'll be able to get ahold of here. May still go for the tigers because I've always loved them and they're readily available...but I definitely feel much better knowing that they won't get eaten!
