Page 1 of 1

ID this Thorny Catfish

Posted: 25 May 2012, 12:32
by amiidae
Nemadoras humeralis ?

Fish is abt 2.5in TL.
Image

Thks

Re: ID this Thorny Catfish

Posted: 25 May 2012, 13:18
by Silurus
Closer to an , I think.

Re: ID this Thorny Catfish

Posted: 25 May 2012, 21:11
by sidguppy
the downward saloping snout is more like Nemadoras, for the rest it's tricky
Opsodoras have pointed noses that turn upwards.

maybe wai till it's settled over sand in a tank and wait till it has it's regular color?

some of the Opsodoras and Nemadoras species have unique dark patches or stripes in the fins and the caudal part of the body; but it's likely these are only well visible once the fish is settled.

Re: ID this Thorny Catfish

Posted: 26 May 2012, 00:47
by amiidae
Here is a clearer shot taken with my cam.

Image

Currently they are in a floating box under observation before I release them into the tank. Yes, they have a dark patch at the dorsal fin if you look carefully on the lower fish.

Re: ID this Thorny Catfish

Posted: 26 May 2012, 07:51
by sidguppy
I think HH is right; the one Opsodoras in the Clog without a pointy nose is
these look a lot like that species

except for the eyes.....the eyes look smaller and round, not large and oval as in O ternetzi

Re: ID this Thorny Catfish

Posted: 26 May 2012, 08:09
by Bas Pels
If you put your mouse here the fish does seam to be quite a bit smaller then the OP's fish

Other fish there look to be larger, and their eyes match the OP's fish much better

Re: ID this Thorny Catfish

Posted: 26 May 2012, 08:24
by sidguppy
but the OP told in his first post that the fish in question are 2.5" TL; that's about 6 cm or so.

which is small.....
Opsodoras ternetzi reaches past twice that size, so it shouldn't have small round eyes at 2.5"

the ones in the Clog are bigger than 2.5", especially the last one and likely the first one as well, given the gravel on the floor

Re: ID this Thorny Catfish

Posted: 28 May 2012, 00:59
by amiidae
Thanks again for the input, guys. :)

I wrote to Dr. Mark Sabaj Perez and was told that this is a new species of Nemadoras related to Nemadoras leporhinus.