PlanetCatfish.com

Hi everyone,

I was wondering about the sexes of these fish.
Can you help me?

2 males.

I kinda thought the bottom one was a female.

Ohw haha, I was thinking maybe the upper one is female...
Can someone tell?

The lower is (most likely) a female. If you compare the head to body width, you see the male has a wider head than the body, the female has a narrower head than body.

--
Mats

Couldn't the lower one be a fat alpha male?

I would expect the head to be wider. But I'm not 100% sure...

--
Mats

They both got to much odontodes to be females, imo.

absolutely 2 males

Top looks male.

Bottom is hard to tell....maybe female.

Funny, these where mine. 100% male and about 2,5-3 years of age.

I have seen her doing this with 2 other peoples fish!! On this forum as well, in the past 2 weeks.
I find it very disrespectful and rude. The photo's aren't yours so you should ask permission to put them on the internet.
You're not making any friend like this madam.

Huh?!

You mean these aren't even the OP's fish nor is it her picture?

Lol, that's rather pointless then.....

Indeed, not her fish and not her pic...

Here the same, not her fish and picture in the forum what is my catfish: What is this little guy?

Lol, that's crazy!

So Sanplec, why would you do something like this?

fish she post are up fore sale and she is planning to buy them
atleast she says in the begining then you hear o shit
and when you mail again she dont want them anny more
for me its oly better coze i got a better deal now

Let's not go on about it. All has been said.
And I hope she will get the message!!
This fishy world is too small to be going behind some ones back As I said, she's not making a load of friends this way....

I can see if you need to confirm an id on a fish that is often confused or the seller has no idea on the species, but we know these are zebras. I think if you can afford to purchase these fish, you should have a good idea of sexing. Just my 2¢

What's all the fuzz about?
I would like to know the sex before I buy a fish, who wouldn't?
These reactions characterize why I'm not present on Dutch forums any more.

It's nothing wrong (assuming you have permission!!) with posting photos of other peoples fish. However, it should be made clear that it is not your own fish - for a variety of reasons:
1. It makes it clear why you are asking (in this case, "I'm planning to buy these, can you please sex them").
2. If someone else sees the picture of a fish for sale, they may either think you are the same person as the one selling the fish, or, worse, think that the seller is selling fish with your picture (it has been known that people advertise fish they don't actually have, with pictures of other people's fish).

The seller may also think it's rather rude to question their statement as to what the fish is (or the sex, etc). The way the post is presented can either make this worse or better...

--
Mats

The bottom one is a fat male. It's head is far too pointy to be a female.

Its customary to ask permission before you post another persons pictures.

+1!

FunkyFredFrog wrote:The bottom one is a fat male. It's head is far too pointy to be a female.

trust me this is A 100% male
seen the fish and the woman owning it knows what shes doing

Apparently，2 male