PlanetCatfish.com

Hello all,

I've noticed that one of my fish is developing Ich in my community tank. It is a 36 gallon with some Danios, Rasbora, corydoras paleatus, a couple BN plecs, and a Betta.

The Betta is breaking out pretty bad now, so I know that I need to treat the whole tank, however I have read a great deal about the negative impact of aquarium salt, sustained high temperatures, and medication on Cory cats.

That said, which is the least of the three evils above? I'd like to obviously rid my tank of this, however I'm not sure how to go about it without killing all my catfish, and Google / other forums are full of conflicting information so I thought I would ask here.

If you have any pointers, please let me know. Thank you.

Best,

Ryan

Asked and answered on another forum. - Frank

Frank, do you mind posting a link to (or a copy of) the answer, in case someone finds this post and wants to know what the answer is?

--
Mats

Greetings. Ryan stated on another forum that he read that most ich medications were potentially harmful to Corys. I posted that I was not aware of any commercial treatments that posed any threat to the well-being of his Corys, if used as recommended.

Additionally, I said that I thought the best course of action would be to QT the betta and treat it, rather than his tank, unless, of course, he could determine that others in the tank, were infected.

Personally, I would teat the tank, also, as the pathogen is present and can start another life-cycle, unless eliminated, completely.

Cheers. - Frank

I saw your answer on TFF, however I tend to disagree about common Ich medications not harming scaleless fish. IE API Super Ick Cure states clearly on it that it may harm scaleless fish and to use 1/2 the normal dose.

I'm just wondering if anyone here has any good or bad experience with some common Ich products so I can purchase the safest one for my Corys.

Rynofasho wrote:I saw your answer on TFF, however I tend to disagree about common Ich medications not harming scaleless fish. IE API Super Ick Cure states clearly on it that it may harm scaleless fish and to use 1/2 the normal dose.

I'm just wondering if anyone here has any good or bad experience with some common Ich products so I can purchase the safest one for my Corys.

I think what Frank said about "when used as recommended" is exactly what the "use half normal dose" is referring to. Some medications should be used at lower dose when used with catfish (and several other types of fish).

--
Mats

I overlooked the part about 'when used as recommended' aka the 1/2 dose. Sorry for the confusion and thank you!

I don't know if this will help at all, but I bought some hatchet fish a few months ago that developed ich in my main tank.

Although none of my other fish looked like they had contracted it , I decided to treat the tank as if they had, I use a product by Mag-Float Labs called "Ick-Ease" http://www.bigalsonline.ca/Fish_Health- ... ml?tc=fish

It says it ok to use at full dosage bottom feeders without raising the tep to 85'F it did not hurt any of my corys as far as I could see, they just carried on as normal, also the ich virus never appeared in my tank again, so I guess that this product works as it says it does.


Cheer's...PanzerFodder...

I'm pretty sure you don't mean 85'C but 85'F.

--
Mats

You are correct Mat, I edited my last post so the temp is correct