Page 1 of 1

What whiptail is this?

Posted: 01 Oct 2009, 13:43
by TopAz
Hello. I am looking for help to identify this species.

Image
They were simply sold as whiptails, being cheaper than the royal whiptails i thought i would buy them and see how they went.
3 years later i still have them both, and still have no clue what they are.

Any ideas?

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 01 Oct 2009, 15:25
by MatsP
Looks like a - which species is pretty hard to say - the most common one is , but they are quite hard to tell apart, as they tend to change colours at the drop of a hat, and other identifying features aren't easily determined.

--
Mats

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 01 Oct 2009, 18:03
by apistomaster
It is very light colored but in shape it resembles . One photo on the profile page show a light colored specimen.
Color and patterns vary but it has that "almost Sturisoma" look that R. lanceolata have.

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 01 Oct 2009, 19:40
by Jon
for me, this is not the best angle to ID rineloricaria-ish species. Although, given your locality, it could very well be LG-6.

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 01 Oct 2009, 19:48
by Karsten S.
Hi,

I think Jon is right.
In the first pic it looks like as if it has two filaments in the dorsal fin. This would exclude Rineloricaria/Hemiloricaria.
In this case it is almost for sure LG 6 which in fact is somehow similar to H. lanceolata in appearance.

Cheers,

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 01 Oct 2009, 19:50
by MatsP
kamas88 wrote:Hi,

I think Jon is right.
In the first pic it looks like as if it has two filaments in the dorsal fin. This would exclude Rineloricaria/Hemiloricaria.
In this case it is almost for sure LG 6 which in fact is somehow similar to H. lanceolata in appearance.

Cheers,
I think you mean caudal (tail) fin has two filaments.

--
Mats

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 01 Oct 2009, 19:52
by Karsten S.
Hi Mats,

right.

Cheers,

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 02 Oct 2009, 05:52
by TopAz
Thankyou for your help. here is another couple of pics to help try and decipher what it is
Image

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 02 Oct 2009, 21:20
by Karsten S.
Hi,

now I'm sure, this is LG 6.

Here a pic of one of mine:
Image

Cheers,

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 06 Oct 2009, 07:47
by TopAz
Sturisoma foerschi thanks for all the help :D

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 06 Oct 2009, 21:10
by Karsten S.
Hi,

a species with the name Sturisoma foerscheri does not exist, this is just a usual trade name for LG 6.
Your fish is 1000% no Sturisoma.

Cheers,

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 06 Oct 2009, 22:13
by racoll
This does look like LG6 (), although I think the same fish is referred to as LG4 in Wels Atlas I?
TopAz wrote:Sturisoma foerschi thanks for all the help
The name "Sturisoma foerschi" should be discouraged from common usage, as it is a nomen nudem, a non-existent species name.

Re: What whiptail is this?

Posted: 07 Oct 2009, 19:28
by Karsten S.
Hi,

right.
It depends on your edition, in the first edition of Welsatlas I this genus is LG 6 and in the second edition it's LG 4.
But most people know this species under the name LG 6.

Cheers,