Super tricky Cory substrate Q
Posted: 22 Oct 2008, 21:19
Hi everyone,
I have been corresponding with the fine folks down at WWM about my cory problem, and they suggested that I try here (heard there are some real cory experts). I will post the correspondence below, and please comment if you have any idea what to do! Thanks!
Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby kletian on Tue Oct 21, 2008 5:26 pm
Hi everyone,
I have a rather complex problem that I've run into. This is a sort of carry-over from my other topic, but it's a different topic so I am making a new thread.
Way back when I first started my 36G, I put in Eco-Complete substrate and 6 cories. The aquarium was moderately planted. Well, for a few months, all was well and the corys were growing bigger and their whiskers were nice. Then, after a few more months, the cories started dying off. I could see that their fins and barbels were deteriorating. Naturally I thought it was because of nitrates, so I took a nitrate test from the bottom of the tank, and it was <10 PPM, the same as elsewhere in the tank. I was sort of perplexed, and I had a couple of cories in my 10G quarantine. I moved the cories over and within a week 1 of them died and the other showed huge fin and barbel decay. So I moved all the remaining cories over to the 10 G, about 5 of them. The 10G tank had just normal blue and white gravel from the pet store, nothing special. For a few months, their fins started growing back... but the barbels never grew back. In fact, the barbels kept getting shorter and shorter, and they all eventually died.
I am wondering what's wrong with my aquarium? I don't think it is dissolved waste, because they have always tested <10 PPM, and of course 0 Ammonia and nitrites (weekly water changes of ~30%). I had been keeping platies and angelfish in the 36G and a beta in the 10G, and no one ever got sick or experienced fin rot... except for the cories. I am wondering what went wrong? Was something wrong with the substrate (aka should I used rounder or smaller gravel?). I am at a loss! I don't want to give up on cories because I love them, but I don't know what else to do! Do you think the dying plant leaves in the 36G contributed to their deaths?
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby Heidi on Tue Oct 21, 2008 6:24 pm
Just some thoughts... What is your ph and hardness? Have you added salt to the tank? I haven't used eco-complete, so can't comment on that. Cories are sensitive to sharp substrate, that we know. What are you feeding? Sinking food? Have you tried a different test kit for nitrates? Are you using the liquid tests or test strips? Do you vacuum the gravel every time you do a water change? Another thought could be waste built up under decorations in the tank, or even under plants like java moss. Since cories are bottom dwellers (with the occasional sprint to the top!), they are exposed to whatever there is on the floor of the tank. Did you buy all of the cories from the same place? Sorry, I'm just throwing ideas out there - I hope you find the cause of the problem soon! Hang in there!
Heidi (aka "MyTai")
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby platytudes on Wed Oct 22, 2008 6:14 am
What I would do, is take a scoop of your substrate, put it in a glass, pour distilled water in (distilled is best, don't use tap or spring water) and stir it up, then let it settle. It might take a while for the water to settle. When it does, test a sample of the distilled water by itself, then test the water in the glass with the Eco-Complete. Compare both readings. The reason I say this is, when I read your post, a little light bulb turned on and I remembered reading about "bad batches"...
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=ba ... gle+Search
See if the tests tell you anything, for example if the substrate alters the pH, hardness, alkalinity, etc. If it doesn't elucidate anything, then next step, I would be calling/e-mailing a CaribSea representative.
The fact that platys didn't get sick in your tank seems to show that you didn't have a problem with pH, alkalinity and hardness dipping down too low (do post those results Heidi mentioned, it would be interesting - another clue!) even though the symptoms you mention really do sound like acidosis. The same sorts of symptoms happen to hard water fish kept in soft water. Do let us know if you used salts or pH altering chemicals...I'm with Heidi's train of thought, this sounds like a water chemistry issue, not a water quality issue.
Keep us posted!
Nicole
Give a man a fish, and he'll eat for a day. Give a fish a man, and he'll eat for weeks!
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby kletian on Wed Oct 22, 2008 7:55 am
Thanks for all the helpful suggestions so far! To answer the questions...
The pH is around 8. I don't know the hardness, but I think our water is quite hard (Southern California). I am feeding the cories sinking shrimp pellets, and whatever else manages to fall to the bottom of the aquarium. I used two different liquid kits for nitrates, and both came out very low (10-20, and < 10). I use a 30-60 gallon tank filter on a 36 gallon tank, and my aquarium is not heavily stocked along with weekly water changes. Every time there is a water change, most of the water comes from the bottom of the tank, as I thoroughly vacuum the gravel with a siphon. Ever since I thought it could be buildup under the java moss, I have gotten rid of all of it, and there is only one piece of driftwood in the tank which is siphoned under. I bought some cories at Petsmart and some at Petco, and regardless of where I bought them, the ones I bought first thrived for a few months before dying, and the ones I bought after just started dying when I put them in the big tank. The big confusing question comes when I look at the effects of moving them into the 10G quarantine; fins grew back but whiskers did not... it seems to slow the rate of death, and the only major difference between the two tanks is that one uses normal gravel and has no plants, and the other had EC with plants. Further, putting them in the 10G quarantine did not allow them to thrive, because they all succumbed before their natural lifespan (maybe last a year or just over a year), so I realize the 10G didn't provide a solid solution either.
I would test the EC, but the cories still died in the 10G tank without EC, so I am not really sure what is wrong... unless there is a problem of substrate in BOTH tanks. The 10G quarantine uses your run of the mill gravel (blue and white) which is not especially smooth (slightly jagged). Of course I would never use salt or pH altering chemicals; those are bad! I only dechlorinate.
Please let me know if you have further thoughts! I love cories but I won't buy any more if I can't keep them alive
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby platytudes on Wed Oct 22, 2008 8:33 am
This turns out to be a real stumper. I would try writing the WWM crew in addition to posting here, and posting on a few different forums, such as planetcatfish.com (where I have read people have gotten responses from reknown cory expert, Ian Fuller) and fishforums.net (where I know Inchworm and Coryologist are two cory experts, and Ian Fuller who goes by the name Coryman there, posts occasionally)...The more people evaluating your situation the better, because your question doesn't have an obvious answer. I'm glad you don't add salt or pH altering chemicals, but you wouldn't believe how many people do, because they have been told that plants can't grow in high pH, or platys like salt...all distortions of the truth. That's why I had to ask, just to make sure!
It sounds to me like the reason the barbels didn't grow back is because whatever wore them away, did so beyond the soft tissue. Same thing happens with finrot, if the damage extends beyond the soft tissue, the tail will not grow back properly or at all. (That's my very unscientific explanation ) Don't get too hung up on the fact that fins grew back and barbels didn't, while it is a point worth mentioning should you consult others, it is probably not indicative of a substrate problem in both tanks...just the extent of the damage to the barbels vs. fins.
You still didn't mention what species of corydoras this was, do mention that when/if you post in other places. Not to sound negative, but I don't know that anyone in this forum is particularly a cory expert, so may have to broaden your horizons...
Give a man a fish, and he'll eat for a day. Give a fish a man, and he'll eat for weeks!
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby sump'nfishy on Wed Oct 22, 2008 8:47 am
perhaps there was a fish picking on them that you didn't see, or they were squabbling at night?
-Danyal
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Thanks for the suggestion. I'll hop on over to planetcatfish and repost my question along with some of your answers. I have emailed WWM and Neal tried to help... except that his suggestions included removing the Java moss and vacuuming the gravel thoroughly, which I do already. As for the wearing of the barbels, some of them I moved to the 10G while only half deteriorated, and they deteriorated the rest of the way (albeit at a much slower rate).
The species of cory are your typical Bronze (Aeneus) Cory, Leopard Cory, and Julii Cory, which are all available from Petco/Petsmart.
This is just not possible in the 10G, as there were only 5 cories and one betta fish.
I have been corresponding with the fine folks down at WWM about my cory problem, and they suggested that I try here (heard there are some real cory experts). I will post the correspondence below, and please comment if you have any idea what to do! Thanks!
Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby kletian on Tue Oct 21, 2008 5:26 pm
Hi everyone,
I have a rather complex problem that I've run into. This is a sort of carry-over from my other topic, but it's a different topic so I am making a new thread.
Way back when I first started my 36G, I put in Eco-Complete substrate and 6 cories. The aquarium was moderately planted. Well, for a few months, all was well and the corys were growing bigger and their whiskers were nice. Then, after a few more months, the cories started dying off. I could see that their fins and barbels were deteriorating. Naturally I thought it was because of nitrates, so I took a nitrate test from the bottom of the tank, and it was <10 PPM, the same as elsewhere in the tank. I was sort of perplexed, and I had a couple of cories in my 10G quarantine. I moved the cories over and within a week 1 of them died and the other showed huge fin and barbel decay. So I moved all the remaining cories over to the 10 G, about 5 of them. The 10G tank had just normal blue and white gravel from the pet store, nothing special. For a few months, their fins started growing back... but the barbels never grew back. In fact, the barbels kept getting shorter and shorter, and they all eventually died.
I am wondering what's wrong with my aquarium? I don't think it is dissolved waste, because they have always tested <10 PPM, and of course 0 Ammonia and nitrites (weekly water changes of ~30%). I had been keeping platies and angelfish in the 36G and a beta in the 10G, and no one ever got sick or experienced fin rot... except for the cories. I am wondering what went wrong? Was something wrong with the substrate (aka should I used rounder or smaller gravel?). I am at a loss! I don't want to give up on cories because I love them, but I don't know what else to do! Do you think the dying plant leaves in the 36G contributed to their deaths?
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby Heidi on Tue Oct 21, 2008 6:24 pm
Just some thoughts... What is your ph and hardness? Have you added salt to the tank? I haven't used eco-complete, so can't comment on that. Cories are sensitive to sharp substrate, that we know. What are you feeding? Sinking food? Have you tried a different test kit for nitrates? Are you using the liquid tests or test strips? Do you vacuum the gravel every time you do a water change? Another thought could be waste built up under decorations in the tank, or even under plants like java moss. Since cories are bottom dwellers (with the occasional sprint to the top!), they are exposed to whatever there is on the floor of the tank. Did you buy all of the cories from the same place? Sorry, I'm just throwing ideas out there - I hope you find the cause of the problem soon! Hang in there!
Heidi (aka "MyTai")
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby platytudes on Wed Oct 22, 2008 6:14 am
What I would do, is take a scoop of your substrate, put it in a glass, pour distilled water in (distilled is best, don't use tap or spring water) and stir it up, then let it settle. It might take a while for the water to settle. When it does, test a sample of the distilled water by itself, then test the water in the glass with the Eco-Complete. Compare both readings. The reason I say this is, when I read your post, a little light bulb turned on and I remembered reading about "bad batches"...
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=ba ... gle+Search
See if the tests tell you anything, for example if the substrate alters the pH, hardness, alkalinity, etc. If it doesn't elucidate anything, then next step, I would be calling/e-mailing a CaribSea representative.
The fact that platys didn't get sick in your tank seems to show that you didn't have a problem with pH, alkalinity and hardness dipping down too low (do post those results Heidi mentioned, it would be interesting - another clue!) even though the symptoms you mention really do sound like acidosis. The same sorts of symptoms happen to hard water fish kept in soft water. Do let us know if you used salts or pH altering chemicals...I'm with Heidi's train of thought, this sounds like a water chemistry issue, not a water quality issue.
Keep us posted!
Nicole
Give a man a fish, and he'll eat for a day. Give a fish a man, and he'll eat for weeks!
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby kletian on Wed Oct 22, 2008 7:55 am
Thanks for all the helpful suggestions so far! To answer the questions...
The pH is around 8. I don't know the hardness, but I think our water is quite hard (Southern California). I am feeding the cories sinking shrimp pellets, and whatever else manages to fall to the bottom of the aquarium. I used two different liquid kits for nitrates, and both came out very low (10-20, and < 10). I use a 30-60 gallon tank filter on a 36 gallon tank, and my aquarium is not heavily stocked along with weekly water changes. Every time there is a water change, most of the water comes from the bottom of the tank, as I thoroughly vacuum the gravel with a siphon. Ever since I thought it could be buildup under the java moss, I have gotten rid of all of it, and there is only one piece of driftwood in the tank which is siphoned under. I bought some cories at Petsmart and some at Petco, and regardless of where I bought them, the ones I bought first thrived for a few months before dying, and the ones I bought after just started dying when I put them in the big tank. The big confusing question comes when I look at the effects of moving them into the 10G quarantine; fins grew back but whiskers did not... it seems to slow the rate of death, and the only major difference between the two tanks is that one uses normal gravel and has no plants, and the other had EC with plants. Further, putting them in the 10G quarantine did not allow them to thrive, because they all succumbed before their natural lifespan (maybe last a year or just over a year), so I realize the 10G didn't provide a solid solution either.
I would test the EC, but the cories still died in the 10G tank without EC, so I am not really sure what is wrong... unless there is a problem of substrate in BOTH tanks. The 10G quarantine uses your run of the mill gravel (blue and white) which is not especially smooth (slightly jagged). Of course I would never use salt or pH altering chemicals; those are bad! I only dechlorinate.
Please let me know if you have further thoughts! I love cories but I won't buy any more if I can't keep them alive
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby platytudes on Wed Oct 22, 2008 8:33 am
This turns out to be a real stumper. I would try writing the WWM crew in addition to posting here, and posting on a few different forums, such as planetcatfish.com (where I have read people have gotten responses from reknown cory expert, Ian Fuller) and fishforums.net (where I know Inchworm and Coryologist are two cory experts, and Ian Fuller who goes by the name Coryman there, posts occasionally)...The more people evaluating your situation the better, because your question doesn't have an obvious answer. I'm glad you don't add salt or pH altering chemicals, but you wouldn't believe how many people do, because they have been told that plants can't grow in high pH, or platys like salt...all distortions of the truth. That's why I had to ask, just to make sure!
It sounds to me like the reason the barbels didn't grow back is because whatever wore them away, did so beyond the soft tissue. Same thing happens with finrot, if the damage extends beyond the soft tissue, the tail will not grow back properly or at all. (That's my very unscientific explanation ) Don't get too hung up on the fact that fins grew back and barbels didn't, while it is a point worth mentioning should you consult others, it is probably not indicative of a substrate problem in both tanks...just the extent of the damage to the barbels vs. fins.
You still didn't mention what species of corydoras this was, do mention that when/if you post in other places. Not to sound negative, but I don't know that anyone in this forum is particularly a cory expert, so may have to broaden your horizons...
Give a man a fish, and he'll eat for a day. Give a fish a man, and he'll eat for weeks!
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Postby sump'nfishy on Wed Oct 22, 2008 8:47 am
perhaps there was a fish picking on them that you didn't see, or they were squabbling at night?
-Danyal
Re: Cory/Substrate Problem
Thanks for the suggestion. I'll hop on over to planetcatfish and repost my question along with some of your answers. I have emailed WWM and Neal tried to help... except that his suggestions included removing the Java moss and vacuuming the gravel thoroughly, which I do already. As for the wearing of the barbels, some of them I moved to the 10G while only half deteriorated, and they deteriorated the rest of the way (albeit at a much slower rate).
The species of cory are your typical Bronze (Aeneus) Cory, Leopard Cory, and Julii Cory, which are all available from Petco/Petsmart.
This is just not possible in the 10G, as there were only 5 cories and one betta fish.