Page 1 of 1

oscar allience

Posted: 05 Dec 2005, 00:19
by declan
i have two pangasius (3") and i was wondering if it was safe to add a couple of oscars to the tank :roll: . oscars have a reputatuon to be very violent towards other fish but the ones in the petshop(2,1/2") are being cept with pangasius(5inches)and are not retalliating. i tought this would be a lesson for them so when they enter my aquarium they won't harass my catfish.

Posted: 05 Dec 2005, 00:48
by Silurus
http://www.planetcatfish.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=4013

All of the relevant points concerning pangasiid husbandry have been covered in this post. Any attempt to start a discussion along the lines of "I want to keep large fish because they will not grow large in my tank/because I want to/because I think I can" will be deemed trolling.

Posted: 05 Dec 2005, 01:09
by declan
thanks for the link, it was just that my mother hated the pangasius catfish and wanted somthing colourful like an oscar or chiclid

Posted: 06 Dec 2005, 23:21
by nolan
Oscars are not as agressive as many people think. yes the will push tank mates around but can easily end up on the loosing side of a fight.
if you got a small oscar, it probably would be ok but as the shark cats grow rapidly and they would be a bit ahead of the oscar.
But oscars are messy fish and need powerful filtration and plenty of water changes or there health can suffer.

if you want a bit less hassle try a severum.

just avoid any central american cichlids big or small as they will probably attack and kill your sharks.

Posted: 08 Dec 2005, 00:08
by declan
messy fish as in managing to turn the water green-yellow or blocking a cheap filter? should they be kept in groups or single?

Posted: 08 Dec 2005, 03:25
by buzz763
I would still suggest Tinfoil barbs, I have 2 pangasius and 4 large Tinfoil barbs and it is a very peaceful coexistence, they don't pick on each other at all. You will have no worries about compatibility.

Posted: 08 Dec 2005, 18:17
by nolan
oscars are messy for the folloowing reasons:

chew up and spit out food poluting the tank
generate vast amounts of waste ammonia etc
dig in the substrate and stir up debris.
and yes a cheap filter will get blocked.
high quality external power filters the way to go.